Life beyond earth: To the sun-like stars
Nasa?s deployment of a space telescope to gaze beyond our solar
system provides the best chance so far of detecting alien
organisms ? intelligent or otherwise, writes Clive Cookson.
A spacecraft launched from Florida offers the best hope yet of
answering a question people have been asking for aeons: Are
there other worlds like ours or are we alone? Nasa?s $600m
(?425m, ?478m) Kepler space telescope was dispatched from Cape
Canaveral to search the galaxy for planets that could harbour
life. The results, says Debra Fisher, astronomy professor at San
Francisco State University, ?will help us chart a course toward
one day imaging a pale blue dot like our planet, orbiting
another star?.
The search for extra-solar planets, or exoplanets, has become
astronomy?s hottest activity. Since 1995, telescopes on Earth
and in space have detected 340 planets elsewhere in the galaxy.
?We know already about an incredibly wild and chaotic range of
planets,? says Prof Fisher. The main point of the planet search,
however, is not to find weird worlds in strange orbits with
bizarre geology. What everyone wants to know is whether there is
life beyond the solar system. If so, its discovery will be among
the most important ever made. It would be the last step in
humanity?s scientific demotion over the past few centuries, by
Copernicus, Darwin and others, from specially created beings at
the centre of the cosmos to just one of myriad life forms in the
universe.
Even if the search for extraterrestrial life is unsuccessful, it
is likely to bring benefits closer to home, in the form of new
ways to discover and study micro-organisms on Earth. All
exoplanets discovered so far are too extreme to support life as
we know it. Kepler ? named after Johannes Kepler (1571-1630),
who discovered that planets travel around the sun in elliptical
orbits ? is the first observatory with technology capable of
finding Earth-sized planets that are neither fireballs nor
snowballs: worlds with liquid water and rocky continents.
William Borucki, the mission?s chief scientist, says it will
survey 100,000 sunlike stars over the next four years, looking
for orbiting planets in the ?habitable zone? ? sometimes known
as the ?Goldilocks zone? ? where conditions ?are not too hot and
not too cold but just right? for life. If Earth-sized planets
are common, Kepler will detect hundreds of them, including
dozens in the habitable zone. ?If we find that many, it will
mean that life may well be common throughout our galaxy,? he
adds. ?If we do not find any, that would be another profound
discovery?, implying that Earth is a lonely outpost of life.
Most astronomers are optimistic, given the latest theories of
planetary formation and the number and variety of giant planets
already discovered. ?We already know enough to say that the
universe is probably loaded with terrestrial planets similar to
Earth,? says Alan Boss of the Carnegie Institution for Science
in Washington. Boss believes that most stars similar in size and
temperature to our sun are accompanied by one or more habitable
planets. Given that there are an estimated 100bn sunlike stars
in our Milky Way galaxy and 100bn galaxies in the known
universe, the potential number of Earth-like planets is a
humbling 10 to the power of 22 (one followed by 22 zeros).
Paul Davies, cosmology professor at Arizona State University,
says there has been a huge change in attitude during his career.
?When I was a student in the 1960s, no one believed that there
was life beyond Earth,? he says. ?Recently the pendulum has
swung in the opposite direction, towards a universe teeming with
life.?
Enthusiasts for exobiology ? life beyond Earth ? are encouraged
not only by the plethora of planets around distant stars but
also by the recent discovery that interstellar space is rich in
organic chemicals. An intensive search with radiotelescopes has
identified 150 molecules by their spectroscopic ?signatures?;
these include complex chemicals such as alcohols, sugars and
amino acids, which are precursors of life.
The origin
The origin of these ?prebiotic? molecules is mysterious. Anthony
Remijan of the US National Radio Astronomy Observatory says they
may form on the surface of interstellar dust grains, heated just
enough by nearby stars to catalyse chemical reactions. Once
formed, prebiotic chemicals could reach the surface of planets,
where a process of proto-evolution would lead the molecules to
organise themselves into increasingly complex self-replicating
forms.
Yet the fact remains that we have evidence for life having
started only once in the universe: On Earth 3.5bn-4bn years ago.
Within our solar system, hopes remain high that, within the next
decade, robot missions to Mars will prove the existence of past
? and perhaps of present ? microbial life. Later missions might
possibly find that some moons of Jupiter and Saturn harbour life
too.
Prof Davies also raises the possibility that life started
independently on Earth on two or more occasions. ?Has there been
a blind spot to the possibility of ?alien? life on Earth?? he
asks. ?Might it exist on Earth today in extreme environments and
remain undetected because our techniques are customised to the
biochemistry of known life?? He advocates a systematic search on
Earth for micro-organisms with an alternative biochemistry to
the DNA, RNA and proteins that control all known forms of life
from viruses and bacteria to humans. ?If we found life happened
more than once here, then it means that the universe really is
teeming with life,? says Prof Davies.
Beyond Earth and the solar system, there is no realistic
possibility of making direct physical contact with alien life.
So astronomers will use an increasingly sophisticated series of
indirect means over the next two or three decades to look for
it. The Kepler space telescope represents the first step. It
will find Earth-like worlds by detecting tiny differences in the
light coming from distant stars as orbiting planets pass in
front of them. The light variations during these ?transits? are
equivalent to an insect flying across a powerful searchlight
beam ? previous observatories have not been powerful enough to
record them.
Astronomers can deduce a surprising amount of information about
a planet by observing a series of transits: its size, from the
way its parent star changes brightness; its orbital period, from
the time between transits; its orbital dimensions, from the
star?s mass and size; and its surface temperature, from its
orbit and the star?s temperature. This will tell whether the
planet is potentially habitable but not, of course, whether it
is inhabited.
After three years of Kepler observations, Nasa expects to have a
reliable estimate for the number of Earth-like planets in our
galaxy. Assuming that those are reasonably plentiful, space
agencies can then plan the next stage: a mission to image
planets directly ? possibly showing clouds, continents and
oceans ? and analyse their atmospheres for chemical signatures
of life, such as oxygen, methane and water. Although the
European Space Agency has such a mission on the drawing board,
called Darwin, and Nasa is thinking of something similar called
Terrestrial Planet Finder, these are unlikely to be funded,
developed and launched in less than 15 years.
The whole process could be short-circuited, however, by a
dramatic coup de th颴re: The detection of signals transmitted by
intelligent beings elsewhere. The search for extraterrestrial
intelligence, known as Seti, started in 1960 at the Green Bank
radiotelescope in West Virginia, under the direction of the
American astronomer Frank Drake. The failure to hear a peep from
ET after almost 50 years has not discouraged advocates of Seti,
who say we have not listened long enough or hard enough ? or in
the right way.
Search
for ET
Nasa had trouble funding Seti in the face of ridicule from
politicians such as the late Senator William Proxmire, a scourge
of what he saw as frivolous public spending. But private donors
stepped in to fill the gap, notably Paul Allen, co-founder of
Microsoft. He has contributed $26m to the construction in
California of an array of 350 radio dishes, each 6 metres in
diameter, dedicated to listening for extraterrestrial signals.
Until now, Seti has had to beg for time on radiotelescopes
designed for other purposes. Estimating how many intelligent
civilisations exist in our galaxy is not much easier today than
it was when Drake published an equation for the purpose in 1961.
?The numbers that came out of the Drake equation then were
between one and 50m,? says Duncan Forgan, an Edinburgh
university astronomer who has just carried out a new
calculation, based on the latest knowledge of planetary
formation and biological evolution. Prof Forgan estimates that
between 360 and 38,000 intelligent life forms capable of
interstellar communications have evolved over the lifetime of
our galaxy so far ? but he says no one can put a sensible figure
on the number of civilisations in existence now, let alone the
chance of picking up a message from one of them.
Even if the Kepler mission gives a good estimate of the number
of habitable planets, we will still have little idea of the
chance that life will actually start, let alone evolve into a
civilisation transmitting radio waves or laser pulses. Perhaps
the biggest uncertainty is how long an average civilisation
exists before it is destroyed. Or, more optimistically, perhaps
some civilisations have become too technologically advanced for
primitive Earthlings of the 21st century to detect signs of
their existence. Astronomers still have little idea of the
identity of the mysterious ?dark matter? and ?dark energy? that
make up 95 per cent of the universe. Could aliens use them to
communicate? Could they even exist in dark matter?
If we do hear from ET, elaborate diplomatic protocols will clank
into action on Earth, to control how the momentous discovery is
disseminated. Any reply to the aliens would have to wait for an
international agreement. Although some astronomers are surprised
that Seti has detected no signs of intelligent life elsewhere,
they do not expect an alien visit to Earth. Short of a
?wormhole? or some other propulsion system beyond the ken of
contemporary physics, the timescales required for interstellar
travel are too vast; it would take several millennia to travel a
few light-years to our nearest planetary neighbours. The energy
required would be prohibitive, too. ?Actual visits would be
ruled out by the laws of physics,? says Boss. Realistically, we
can expect to know within 20-30 years whether there is life of
some sort beyond Earth. As for intelligent life, we may have to
wait an eternity.
The meaning of life is of increasing interest to scientists as
well as philosophers. As the search for extraterrestrial life
gathers pace, the exobiologists who specialise in this are
studying the potential range of chemical and physical
characteristics in living systems. Silicon-based life has
featured in science fiction but most chemists say only
carbon-based systems such as on Earth would be versatile and
robust enough to evolve elsewhere.
These would have to follow the rules of organic chemistry - and
of Darwinian evolution. ?Whatever its shape or chemistry, there
is one important expectation that many if not all biologists
share about life in the universe,? says Sean Carroll, professor
of genetics at the University of Chicago. ?Wherever life has
arisen, it has evolved by the two principles Darwin formulated:
By descent with modification and natural selection.?
A universal requirement for life, then, is a biochemical store
of genetic information passed down through the generations, with
small changes to make evolution possible. On Earth this role is
carried out by the DNA and RNA molecules, which carry data on
chemical letters called nucleotides. Although scientists have
not thought up a completely different genetic system, they have
developed alternative forms of DNA incorporating synthetic
nucleotides.
Last month at the American Association for the Advancement of
Science meeting in Chicago, Steven Benner announced the first
laboratory experiment in which artificial DNA underwent
Darwinian evolution. ?If you are looking for alien life, it is
helpful to have an alternative system to study,? says Dr Benner
of the Foundation for Applied Molecular Evolution in Florida.
Instead of carrying out ?wet? experiments in a biochemistry lab,
a different approach uses computers and software to simulate the
creation of life under various conditions elsewhere in the
universe. On an Earth-like planet, with oceans, continents and
climate broadly similar to ours, any advanced life forms would
probably not look wildly different to their terrestrial
counterparts. For example, the history of life on Earth shows
that features such as eyes and ears, which give organisms a huge
competitive advantage, evolved independently on several
occasions. It is conceivable, however, that any super-advanced
civilisation could be unrecognisable to ours, if biological
organisms have melded with machine intelligence to form some
sort of hybrid biocomputer life form. The concept is
controversial, but some futurists such as Ray Kurzweil predict
that something like it will happen on Earth later this century.
Source: The
peninsola
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 Newest
articles
|