Fermilab, the U.S. maker of the Tevatron accelerator, is
claiming it’s European rival, particle physics lab CERN, is
rapidly losing ground in the race to discover the elusive Higgs
boson, or "God particle," BBC News reported.
Theoreticians predict the “God Particle” would help to explain
why matter has mass and is a major goal of CERN's Large Hadron
However, Fermilab says the odds of its detecting the famed
particle first are now 50-50 at worst, and up to 96% at best.
Both machines are designed to collide sub-atomic matter at very
high speeds in hopes that the Higgs will emerge from the debris.
Last September, an accident damaged some of the magnets that
make up the LHC’s giant colliding ring. Repair work is still
under way on the atom smasher.
The enforced downtime might cost the European lab one of the
biggest prizes in physics, Project leader Lyn Evans said.
Officials from CERN and Fermilab were at the American
Association for the Advancement of Science (AAAS) annual meeting
The European Organization for Nuclear Research (CERN)
constructed the LHC in the early 1980s in an attempt to identify
the so-called God Particle.
Some scientists at the LHC’s September launch near Geneva
predicted the Higgs would be revealed as soon as summer 2009,
but an accident occurred only a week later that is expected to
stall the accelerator for at least 12 months.
Given the LHC’s downtime, Fermilab has increased the intensity
of research at their Tevatron accelerator in Illinois.
Director Pier Oddone presented the Tevatron’s latest data at the
His Fermilab colleague, Dr. Dmitri Denisov, said they now have a
very good chance of seeing hints of the Higgs before the LHC
"I think we have the next two years to find it, based on the
start date Lyn Evans has told us. The probability of our
discovering the Higgs is very good - 90% if it is in the high
mass range. And the chances are even higher - 96% - if its mass
is around 170GeV (giga-electron volts).
"In that case we would be talking about seeing hints of the
Higgs by this summer."
Oddone said the smaller the mass of the particle, the more
difficult and time-consuming it will be for Fermilab to detect.
“Even at the lowest end of the range, the chances are 50% or
above,” he suggested.
Denisov added that Tevatron is running extremely well and they
are increasing their data-set very quickly.
LHC scientists said instead of having their usual two-month
Christmas break, they are planning to run all the way through.
"It's a race. Whoever is first is first."
The Tevatron has already picked out about eight collision
events, which may be hints of the Higgs, Fermilab said, adding
that until the number crunching is done, it is not possible to
distinguish these from "background noise".
Professor Lyn Evans, the LHC’s project leader, agreed the
Tevatron is working better than he ever imagined it could and is
accumulating data like mad.
However, he said the LHC has given them an extra time window
they’ve certainly been making the most of.
Evans said: “If they do find the Higgs, good luck to them. But I
think it's unlikely they will find it before the LHC comes
online. They may well be in a position to get a hint of the
Higgs but I don't think they'll be in a position to discover
“Pier Oddone put the odds at 50-50 but I think it's less than
that,” he said. "In one year, we will be competitive. After
that, we will swamp them."
Evans agreed the competition was healthy for "both parties",
although missing out on the Higgs would be a "sour consolation",
"But don't forget, there is also a whole spectrum of physics to
be investigated at the LHC which the Tevatron can never do."
Image Caption: The Tevatron accelerator in Batavia,