Two spiral galaxies,
satellite view. Photograph: StockTrek/Getty Images
When Dr Chris Lintott, a
researcher in the department of physics at the University of
Oxford, first considered launching a website to ask the
public to help classify photographs of 1m galaxies, he
assumed it would probably take three or four years to
complete. Galaxy Zoo (galaxyzoo.org),
launched in July 2007, was supposed to be a side project;
instead it has turned into the biggest citizen-science
experiment on the web.
Galaxies can be classified as
spiral, elliptical or merging (when two come together). The
Sloan Digital Sky Survey, or SDSS (www.sdss.org),
has images of nearly a million galaxies; what those images
don't have in their raw form is the information about what
class of galaxy is pictured.
Lintott had hoped that each
image would get 10 classifications, or "clicks", and that
the public would prove able to classify galaxies accurately
according to their features. Three weeks and 10m clicks
later, he was proved right: the public is capable of
classifying galaxies as well as, or even better than,
professional astronomers. And quickly, too. "It was like
being hit by a tidal wave," says Lintott.
The images have now had more
than 70m clicks in total, allowing Lintott and his team to
go beyond simply sorting galaxies into spiral, elliptical or
merging categories, into further research. "You can have
confidence, as we can say, '100% of people think that's a
spiral galaxy, so it's really, really spirally'," says
Lintott.
Human zoo
His team was allocated precious
time on the IRAM 30m radio telescope in southern Spain, and
was easily able to select just 40 galaxies from the original
sample to study, safe in the knowledge that the scientists
had exactly what they needed.
After Galaxy Zoo's initial
success, Lintott wanted to take a closer look at merging
galaxies. At 5pm one Tuesday he posted a spreadsheet listing
a selection to the forums and asked members to take a look
and email him the best. Then he went to the pub.
One "Zooite", Richard Proctor,
a telecoms consultant, spotted the spreadsheet and thought:
"I can build a webpage to do that!" By the time Lintott
logged back in, the web interface was already in use.
"What was going to be a quick
little study turned into a much larger study of about 45,000
images," says Proctor. Each image has now had more than 25
clicks, with four particularly committed souls having seen
every single one. The first academic paper about those
merging galaxies has been submitted, and Proctor
is listed as a co-author.
It's not the first time
collaborative astronomy has
proved a hit online. The Search for Extraterrestrial
Intelligence (Seti) project created the most powerful
distributed computer ever with its Seti@home project
launched in May 1999, which used spare processing power on
home computers to process data collected from a specific
wavelength to see if aliens were trying to get in touch. It
was used by 5.2 million people and offered, at its peak, 265
teraflops (a trillion calculations a second) of processing
power.
Similarly, Nasa's Clickworkers
project in 2000-01, found that ordinary people were just as
good as astronomers at identifying craters on Mars in
photos.
The biggest influence on Galaxy
Zoo, however, is Stardust@home, where users search for tiny
interstellar dust particles within images returned by the
2006 Stardust mission. Thousands of users have logged on to
the site.
"Stardust@home was a real
inspiration for us," says Lintott. "We thought, 'If 20,000
people will look for dust grains in their spare time, surely
they will look at beautiful pictures of galaxies?'"
But unlike those projects,
where the task is set from the top down, the Galaxy Zoo
community has its own ideas about what can be done with the
SDSS data.
"Up until now," says Proctor,
"the professional astronomers have come up with things that
want classifying and we've classified them." But there are
thousands of irregular galaxies - neither spiral nor
elliptical - that the professionals don't have time to
examine. So the community decided to do it themselves,
drafting a list of questions and building a web interface to
make classification easier.
"Once we've got some results,"
promises Proctor, "we'll publish them for everybody to use,
and then see if we can find out anything useful. Given that
the biggest study of irregular galaxies to date looked at
around 150, and we've got 9,000, we must find something!"
Lintott is supportive of the
irregulars project: "They are doing everything professional
astronomers would do," he says. "It's up there with any work
I've done."
It's not just the volume of
research that can be done by collaborating with the public
that's important to Lintott, but also the opening up of
scientific research to anyone with a browser and a little
time.
"By making the data available
to everyone," he says, "whatever stage you are in your
learning, you can do research."
And a surprising cross-section
of people are doing just that. Hanny van Arkel is a Dutch
primary school teacher who discovered a strange object, now
called Hanny's Voorwerp (Dutch for "object"), near a spiral
galaxy. "I thought it was fun," she says of Galaxy Zoo, "but
I didn't expect that it would become such a big part of my
life. I've learned a lot and it's a good way of
participating in science."
Elisabeth Baeten, a Belgian
secretary, is one of only four people who has seen every
image in the galaxy merger project. "I also classify the
irregulars," she says, "and in between I cruise the universe
looking for asteroids and gravitational lenses."
In future, it will be much
easier for both scientists and enthusiasts to take part in
such projects. Not only are Lintott and his colleagues
finalising Galaxy Zoo 2, which will examine galaxies in much
more detail, they are also building a platform that will
allow any scientist to upload data and tap into the vast
potential of the internet.
"Our users are clamouring for
stuff to do," says Lintott. "The problem of having too much
data to pay close attention to is not just an astronomical
problem. It's astronomical in scale, but it's not just us."
The new project will allow
scientists to upload their videos of elephants, pictures of
galaxies, or chemical structures, then specify what they
want done with them. They can either use the provided
templates, or customise their project. Lintott describes it
as the scientific version of the popular blogging software
WordPress.
And there are many uses of such
a platform. Nasa has high-quality images from the Mars
Reconnaissance Orbiter, most of which are simply filed. And
study of the pictures produced by this year's Lunar
Reconnaissance Orbiter will allow scientists to build a
history of asteroid bombardment of the inner solar system.
"It's like Nasa does the map
and we'll write the guide book," says Lintott.
Indeed, it would be possible
for anyone to upload data, including amateur astronomers.
"More than a million separate observations a year are
recorded by amateurs," says Lintott. "That's a huge pile of
data that, at the minute, professionals slowly sort through,
but we can hand that back to the amateurs to analyse.